For War or Peace

    


Issues of war and peace in the twenty first century


Enter Email to be added
our email list


Forget Red Lines: Obama Should Eat His Words on Syria  Adil E. Shamoo

Forget Red Lines: Obama Should Eat His Words on Syria

Share
obama-red-line-syria-chemical-weapons-military-intervention-assad

(V.H. Hammer / Flickr)

The good news? President Obama’s surprise decision to consult Congress about launching a U.S. strike on Syria has returned crucial powers to the people’s representatives, allowing a much-needed public discussion about the U.S. stake—or lack thereof—in Syria’s civil war.

The bad news? Obama has claimed the authority to attack Syria no matter what Congress decides. This arrogance, which mirrors America’s own hubris on the world stage, will no doubt escalate the threat of terrorism against the United States and could embroil the country in a broader Middle Eastern war.

The White House has justified its proposed attack by asserting that Bashar al-Assad’s alleged use of chemical weapons violated international “standards” and “norms.” However, if the Obama administration does go ahead with its proposed strikes, the United States itself will be acting in violation of international law. According to the U.N. Charter, the United Nations “prohibits any and all use of force against other states, except for the purpose of individual or collective self-defense, or as authorized by the U.N. Security Council for the purposes of restoring or maintaining collective security.” None of these conditions currently apply.

The president and his national security team have apparently already concluded that intervention in Syria serves America’s interests, and appear determined to act accordingly. Chemical weapons merely provide a justification to assert those interests, among which are to ensure access to oil and to help allies, especially Israel, in the Middle East. Moreover, the intervention has a global and regional component: the administration is warning the Russian Federation and China that the United States will defend its interests in the Middle East, with military force if necessary. As for Iran, it is a warning that the United States is determined to reduce Iranian influence in the region, sending a signal that Washington has the will and capability to retaliate if Iran decides to develop nuclear weapons.

What are the facts of the case? Obama has concluded “that the Syrian government, in fact, carried out” a chemical attack on civilians, and that we need to send “a pretty strong signal that they better not do it again.” Secretary of State John Kerry claimed that the White House has overwhelming evidence and “high confidence” that the government of Syria used chemical weapons, and released a declassified intelligence dossier to back up these charges. But the United States does not in fact have ironclad proof that Assad used chemical weapons in August. To be sure, the UN envoy has suggested that some chemical substance was used but has not released any definitive findings about the culprit. While it’s likely that Assad is guilty, it is also conceivable that a rogue military unit or a segment of the rebel opposition could be the culprit.

Many well-meaning people believe the United States must intervene on humanitarian grounds in order to stop Assad from using chemical weapons on his people again. But while protecting civilians and preventing future tragedies is vital, there are strong reasons not to trust the motivations of the people pushing this war, or the likely outcomes of the proposed military intervention.

History provides important lessons in this regard. The supposed weapons of mass destruction (“WMD”) in Iraq green-lighted the overthrow of Saddam Hussein in 2003, leading to years of war and almost innumerable deaths. The Gulf of Tonkin incident in 1964 led to a lengthy U.S. ground war in Vietnam. Pursuing U.S. “interests” led to the 1953 overthrow of the democratically elected government of Mohammad Mosaddegh in Iran. During the Iran-Iraq war in the 1980s, the United States secretly gave arms to Iran (part of the Iran-Contra affair) while providing intelligence to Iraq on the location of Iranian troops, knowing full well Saddam Hussein would use his chemical weapons against them. This track record should inspire little confidence among actual humanitarians.

The Obama administration has emphasized that any attack on Syria would be a “limited” intervention that would not involve “boots on the ground” or lead to a wider war. Yet Secretary Kerry’s recent remarks about Syria were tantamount to a declaration of war. Kerry called the use of chemical weapons an “indiscriminate slaughter of civilians” and a “moral obscenity,” evoking the equally strident tone used by Secretary of State Colin Powell about Iraq’s WMDs—which, as we know now, turned out to be non-existent.

Meanwhile, many commentators and analysts are nearly hysterical in their support for intervention in Syria. Some suggest Obama will be considered weak if he does not act. Many of them are the same neoconservatives who championed the invasion of Iraq. They are gunning for an attack on Damascus and said so in a recent letter to President Obama advocating for full regime change so that Assad will “no longer threaten America” or “our allies in the region.”

In planning a military attack, the United States is increasingly isolated. Not a single Arab government is openly supporting U.S. military action. (Although several Arab regimes would be happy to see Assad go, they rightly fear their own citizens’ reaction to any American intervention.) Aside from France, Western allies are not rushing to support the United States either. The British parliament soundly defeated a request by Prime Minister David Cameron to join the coalition, and Cameron respected that decision. Consequently, the United States is acting without broad backing by an international community.

Many who support a military intervention in Syria do not address the possible and probable reactions of Iran, Hezbollah, or the Arab streets in Jordan and Iraq. An escalated war in Syria could spread into Lebanon, Iraq, and Jordan, and would very probably engage Iran. The White House claims it will not pursue regime change in Syria, but we all know what happened to Muammar Gaddafi in Libya just two years ago.

How will the United States respond when Middle East actors retaliate with terrorist acts? It is unreasonable to expect that military intervention will be met with silence. It is very likely that the United States will become mired in a war in the Middle East. Syria will then become a secondary consideration as the fuse of discontent is lit among Arabs against the United States.

All this will happen because a talkative president made “Assad must go,” “red-line,” and “game changer” part of his vocabulary. But sometimes it’s better to eat your words than repeat them.

Adil E. Shamoo is an associate fellow of the Institute for Policy Studies, a senior analyst for Foreign Policy in Focus, and the author of Equal Worth – When Humanity Will Have Peace. He can be reached at ashamoo@som.umaryland.edu.

    Printer Friendly Version



Articles
If Obama had never become presid....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 08, 2014

Political Complexity in the Midd....
Interview with Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 07, 2014

Israel-Palestine: Enough Negotia....
Adil E. Shamoo
Nov 25, 2013

egypt?s dark tunnel....
adil e. shamoo
Oct 29, 2013

Discussion (Arabic)....
Interview on Orient TV (Syria) with Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 11, 2013

a new approach for israel?....
walter pincus
Oct 03, 2013

Have you heard of th....
Sameer
Sep 24, 2013

Syria: Do We Have An Obligation ....
Adil E. Shamoo/on Marc Steiner Show/An NPR Baltimore station
Sep 06, 2013

Forget Red Lines: Obama Should E....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 05, 2013

Intervention in Syria/ Mark Stei....
Adil E. Shamoo
Aug 28, 2013

Egypt Speaks, Again....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Jul 05, 2013

Midday Politics: Syria: Tuesday ....
Adil E. Shamoo on WYYP, Blatimore NPR station
Jun 25, 2013

On the Brink of Another War....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Jun 20, 2013

Analysis of the conflict occurri....
Adil E. Shamoo on Marc Steiner Show
May 30, 2013

After Iraq, Climbing Out of the ....
Adil E. Shamoo
Apr 02, 2013

10-Year Anniversary Of The Iraq ....
Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 19, 2013

The Monitor/The Mark Bebawi show....
An interview with Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 18, 2013

morsi's last chance....
adil e. shamoo
Feb 11, 2013

Radio interview of Adil E. Shamo....
Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 11, 2013

Is Iraq on its Way to a Civil Wa....
Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 08, 2013

Yup, that shuold def....
Fadly
Dec 11, 2012

Hitham's Tale....
Adil E. Shamoo
Nov 29, 2012

Petraeus Fell for the Wrong Reas....
Sheldon Richman
Nov 20, 2012

Interview on RT television on Is....
Adil E. Shamoo
Nov 15, 2012

The Looming Sunni-Shia Crisis....
Kelley Vlahos - Citing Adil E. Shamoo
Nov 09, 2012

Interview on the Presidential de....
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 23, 2012

Romney on the Middle East: Obama....
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 10, 2012

An interview with Adil E. Shamoo....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 25, 2012

No to War with Iran....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 18, 2012

Interview on the recent killing ....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 12, 2012

This was so helpful ....
Mariana
Sep 01, 2012

The Marc Steiner Show....
Interview with Adil E. Shamoo on Syria
Aug 14, 2012

Sharks Bleeding Syria for its Ca....
Adil E. Shamoo
Aug 08, 2012

Who Makes Stuff Up, And Why They....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jul 31, 2012

Have you heard of th....
Etr
Jun 29, 2012

Egypt's Path Winds Toward Democr....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
May 30, 2012

Morals in the Age of One Superpo....
Adil E. Shamoo
May 09, 2012

Principled Intervention in Syria....
Adil E. Shamoo
May 01, 2012

Principled Intervention in Syria....
Adil E. Shamoo
Apr 27, 2012

In Iraq, occupation by another n....
Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 16, 2012

Syria's Revolution Will Succeed....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 13, 2012

This info is the cat....
Nilza
Dec 29, 2011

Panel discussion on the United S....
Interview with Adil E. Shamoo with Marc Steiner Show
Dec 22, 2011

Arab Islamists Are Here to Stay....
Adil E. Shamoo
Dec 16, 2011

It's a pleasure to f....
Curves
Nov 29, 2011

Egypt cabinet resigning after th....
Adil E. Shamoo (Interview with RTV)
Nov 21, 2011

An interview on Marc Steiner Sho....
Adi E. Shamoo
Nov 08, 2011

Bahrain's Courageous Doctors....
Adil E. Shamoo,
Nov 07, 2011

Is U.S. really leaving Iraq?....
Adil E. Shamoo and Bonnie Bricker
Oct 25, 2011

The Upcoming Palestinian Uprisin....
Adil E. Shamoo
Aug 23, 2011

U.S. needs to completely withdra....
Adil E. Shamoo and Bonnie Bricker
Jun 13, 2011

No Moral Consistency in Obama's ....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Apr 08, 2011

Interview with Shamoo on Libya....
Adil Shamoo
Mar 24, 2011

An interview on WEAA/local NPR r....
Adil Shamoo
Mar 21, 2011

Shamoo Interview with Russian TV....
Shamoo
Mar 20, 2011

Strategic Dialogue: Intervene or....
Islam Qasem and Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 18, 2011

I call on the Nation....
Santiago
Mar 16, 2011

NATO Emergency Talks in Brussel ....
Interview with Shamoo
Mar 11, 2011

Iraqi Protests Make Washington S....
Interview with Shamoo
Mar 08, 2011

Children of War....
Interview with Shamoo
Mar 07, 2011

Interview with Shamoo....
Libyan warplanes strike as rebels advance on capital
Mar 06, 2011

Libyan Migrants....
Interview with Shamoo
Mar 04, 2011

Interview with Adil Shamoo on Vo....
Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 02, 2011

Interview with Shamoo on Too lit....
Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 02, 2011

No to Military Intervention in L....
Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 25, 2011

Interview with Shamoo on RTTV....
Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 24, 2011

Is Egypt's New Military Leadersh....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 14, 2011

Washington's Support for Another....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 09, 2011

On the Wrong Side of History in ....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 31, 2011

The threat of bad science....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 11, 2011

Who Assassinated Iraqi Academics....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 06, 2011

If Israel Wants Peace.......
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 25, 2010

WikiLeaks: U.S. Soldiers Left Wo....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 25, 2010

Major Advances Demand Moral Lead....
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 06, 2010

Secrecy industry hits home....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Jul 26, 2010

Are Foreign Lives of Equal Worth....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jun 16, 2010

Worst Fears May be Realized In I....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
May 25, 2010

Iraq's Baby Steps Toward Democra....
Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 30, 2010

Iraq Policy: D....
Bonnie Bricker and Adil E. Shamoo
Feb 05, 2010

Obama'd Mixed Policy and Message....
Adil E. Shamoo,
Jan 27, 2010

WHO HATES HAITI? The Iraqis Ough....
Michael Springmann
Jan 23, 2010

How Not to Fight Terrorism!....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jan 13, 2010

? ?? ? ? ? ?? ???? ....
Vickey
Jan 05, 2010

Nation-Building in Afghanistan....
Adil E. Shamoo
Nov 30, 2009

Next in Afghanistan: Learning Fr....
Adil E. Shamoo and Bonnie Bricker, November 24, 2009
Nov 24, 2009

Woot, I will ceiartn....
Sony
Oct 01, 2009

Israel killed Palestinians wavin....
Ilene R. Prusher
Aug 13, 2009

Tough Questions Nobody Wants to ....
MORTON ABRAMOWITZ
Aug 10, 2009

The Future of Iraq (FIG) Report ....
Future of Iraq Group
Aug 01, 2009

Iraq: Nightmare or New Democracy....
Adil E. Shamoo and Bonnie Bricker
Jul 24, 2009

A Just War....
Donald R. McClarey
Jul 01, 2009

A Global Public Health Policy Ba....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B. 2009.
Jun 17, 2009

Obama's Speech: Vexing Issues....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jun 10, 2009

How Not to Support Democracy in ....
Stephen Zunes
Jun 08, 2009

Breaking the Silence....
Soldiers’ Testimonies from Operation Cast Lead, Gaza 2009
Jun 01, 2009

Israel's actions defended - GAZA....
Jordan Press
May 13, 2009

The Anti-War Dilemma: How To Pro....
Dawn Teo
May 11, 2009

You have more useful....
Suresh
May 10, 2009

Martyrdom's Strategy: Suicide Bo....
Steve Niva
May 05, 2009

Obama's First 100 Days: Foreign ....
John Feffer, This article appears in Thirsting for Change: Obama's First 100 Days, a report published by the Institute for Policy Studies.
Apr 27, 2009

Mar10Neil Thapa T....
Sheryl
Mar 26, 2009

They Voted for One Iraq, The Bal....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B. 2009. Op-Ed
Feb 10, 2009

Ethics of Nation-Building and it....
Shamoo, A. E.
Dec 03, 2008

Obama's Top Three Foreign Policy....
Shamoo, A. E.
Nov 07, 2008

A bold step for US good will in ....
Shamoo, A. E.
Nov 04, 2008

"Georgia, Iraq, and Athenian Jus....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bonnie Bricker
Sep 09, 2008

yp our voting sytesm....
Vitin
Jun 20, 2008

"A Moral Burden on U.S. Soldiers....
Shamoo, A. E.
May 30, 2008

Freedom, Democracy, and Death in....
Shamoo, A. E.
Apr 08, 2008

Immoral: Ignoring the Routine Ki....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B
Apr 05, 2008

If you wrote an arti....
Triya
Mar 12, 2008

The Enduring Trap in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.
Jan 21, 2008

Wining or Losing in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.
Dec 17, 2007

The Surgeon Fails in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.,
Nov 28, 2007

The Costs of War for Oil....
Bricker, B. and Shamoo, A. E.,
Oct 19, 2007

If You Want Peace in Iraq, Stop ....
Shamoo, A. E.
Sep 14, 2007

Who will cry for innocent Iraqis....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Sep 05, 2007

America should leave Iraq, but f....
Shamoo, A. E.
Jul 16, 2007

Victory in Iraq?", ....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Jun 21, 2007

The Destruction of Iraqi Healthc....
Shamoo, A. E.
May 31, 2007

The problem with building an emb....
Shamoo, A. E.
Mar 20, 2007

Iraqis in Despair....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Mar 12, 2007

Corruption and Ethics: Number On....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Nov 16, 2006

Sprouting from Inequity: The Roo....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Oct 12, 2006

At War With Syria and Iran, the ....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B. 2006
Aug 10, 2006

Commentary: “Serious Harm By Res....
Shamoo, A. E. (Appeared in more than 15 newspapers worldwide)
May 06, 2006

Permanent U.S. Bases in Iraq are....
Shamoo, A. E.
Apr 16, 2006

Iraq and the Problem of Terroris....
Shamoo, A. E.
Jan 24, 2006

Can the Iraqi Insurgency be Neut....
Shamoo, A. E.
Nov 21, 2005

Looking for Peace in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.
Sep 16, 2005

1....
1
Dec 31, 1899

1....
1
Dec 31, 1899