For War or Peace


Issues of war and peace in the twenty first century

Enter Email to be added
our email list

America should leave Iraq, but for the right reasons  Shamoo, A. E.,0,7871495.story?coll=bal-oped-headlines

From the Baltimore Sun

America should leave Iraq, but for the right reasons

By Adil E. Shamoo

July 16, 2007

"Our course in Iraq has lost contact with our vital national security interests in the Middle East and beyond. ... The vitality of the U.S. economy and the economies of much of the world depend on the oil that comes from the Persian Gulf."

With these statements, Republican Sen. Richard G. Lugar of Indiana, ranking minority member of the Foreign Relations Committee, recently came out against the war in Iraq. The speech ran 5,644 words, with frequent mention of the importance of Middle Eastern oil.

Nowhere in the speech was there any mention of the rights and interests of the Iraqi people. Without this recognition of the results our actions have had on the lives of Iraqis, we will continue to find ourselves haunted by the aftermath of actions based on immoral decisions.

I applaud and wholeheartedly agree with the reasons given by Senator Lugar and others for leaving Iraq - those of national interest. But you would think that Iraqi interests would deserve a mention. This war has led to the deaths of hundreds of thousands and the wounding and traumatizing of millions of Iraqis. More than 4 million refugees - half of them children - have been forced to leave their homes. Unemployment is over 50 percent.

The health care infrastructure is destroyed; more than 2,000 physicians have been killed, and many thousands more have fled the country. Iraqi girls as young as 12 have resorted to prostitution in their desperation to support their families. The education system also has been destroyed. Yet many of our politicians, fearful of being labeled as soft on defense, resort to blaming the Iraqis because they have not met our "benchmarks."

The reports of death and destruction in Iraq have become so routine that major media outlets now relegate the deaths of dozens of Iraqis to minor coverage; meanwhile, Paris Hilton recently got almost two hours of coverage on CNN in a single evening.

Most Americans are moral and fair, once we know the facts. If the American people were to see and feel the pain and suffering of individual Iraqis, I am certain the moral outrage about what is happening in Iraq would be intense. The troops would be home sooner rather than later. But our leaders - Republicans and Democrats - first must know the real pain and suffering of the Iraqi people.

Individual Americans donate billions of dollars to total strangers in a devastated area or because of the HIV/AIDS scourge. Americans fly all over the world to adopt orphans. Our people are good, but our government is no longer as good as its people. We now know that the facts about Iraq as given to us before the war by the president and his advisers were not true. Now it is up to our legislators to right this wrong perpetrated on the American - and Iraqi - people.

Legislative leaders such as Senator Lugar need to demonstrate leadership by informing the American people that our moral compass is working and that we should leave Iraq not simply because it is in our interests, but because it is the right thing to do. We will only begin to find peace in this region when our strength is shown in our moral and human acts, not just in our military might.

We can begin by telling the American people that we will leave Iraq in an orderly and safe manner and by apologizing to the Iraqi people for the havoc we have wreaked.

Adil E. Shamoo, who was born and raised in Baghdad, is a professor at the University of Maryland School of Medicine and a contributor to Foreign Policy in Focus. His e-mail is

Copyright © 2007, The Baltimore Sun | Get Sun home delivery


    Printer Friendly Version

Repeating our Middle East mistak....
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 30, 2014

Ebola: Quarantines and Transmiss....
Adil E. Shamoo
Oct 29, 2014

Islamic State Update....
Adil E. Shamoo (with other two guests)
Sep 29, 2014

Treat ISIS Like an Onion....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 11, 2014

Iraq in Crisis: Understanding th....
Adil E. Shamoo
Sep 03, 2014

Israel's unjust war....
Adil E. Shamoo
Aug 01, 2014

Debating the Situation in Gaza....
Debate with Adil E. Shamoo and Jay Bernstein
Jul 30, 2014

Israel Terrorizes Palestinians i....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jul 18, 2014

Adil Shamoo on Iraqi government ....
Adil Shamoo (In Arabic)
Jun 30, 2014

Middle East Roundtable: ISIS, Ir....
Adil E. Shamoo debating with two guests
Jun 26, 2014

Iraq Elections: No End to Violen....
Adil E. Shamoo
May 29, 2014

Egypt's Fateful Choice: Democrac....
Adil E. Shamoo,
Apr 06, 2014

Obama’s Changing Moral Compass o....
Adl E. Shamoo
Apr 04, 2014

The Marc Steiner Show....
Interview with Adil E. Shamoo on Syria
Aug 14, 2012

Morals in the Age of One Superpo....
Adil E. Shamoo
May 09, 2012

Arab Islamists Are Here to Stay....
Adil E. Shamoo
Dec 16, 2011

An interview on WEAA/local NPR r....
Adil Shamoo
Mar 21, 2011

Strategic Dialogue: Intervene or....
Islam Qasem and Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 18, 2011

Interview with Adil Shamoo on Vo....
Adil E. Shamoo
Mar 02, 2011

The Future of Iraq (FIG) Report ....
Future of Iraq Group
Aug 01, 2009

Iraq: Nightmare or New Democracy....
Adil E. Shamoo and Bonnie Bricker
Jul 24, 2009

A Global Public Health Policy Ba....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B. 2009.
Jun 17, 2009

Obama's Speech: Vexing Issues....
Adil E. Shamoo
Jun 10, 2009

Breaking the Silence....
Soldiers’ Testimonies from Operation Cast Lead, Gaza 2009
Jun 01, 2009

Israel's actions defended - GAZA....
Jordan Press
May 13, 2009

The Anti-War Dilemma: How To Pro....
Dawn Teo
May 11, 2009

Martyrdom's Strategy: Suicide Bo....
Steve Niva
May 05, 2009

Obama's First 100 Days: Foreign ....
John Feffer, This article appears in Thirsting for Change: Obama's First 100 Days, a report published by the Institute for Policy Studies.
Apr 27, 2009

Ethics of Nation-Building and it....
Dec 03, 2008

A bold step for US good will in ....
Shamoo, A. E.
Nov 04, 2008

Freedom, Democracy, and Death in....
Shamoo, A. E.
Apr 08, 2008

The Enduring Trap in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.
Jan 21, 2008

Wining or Losing in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.
Dec 17, 2007

The Surgeon Fails in Iraq....
Shamoo, A. E.,
Nov 28, 2007

The Costs of War for Oil....
Bricker, B. and Shamoo, A. E.,
Oct 19, 2007

If You Want Peace in Iraq, Stop ....
Shamoo, A. E.
Sep 14, 2007

America should leave Iraq, but f....
Shamoo, A. E.
Jul 16, 2007

Victory in Iraq?", ....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Jun 21, 2007

The Destruction of Iraqi Healthc....
Shamoo, A. E.
May 31, 2007

The problem with building an emb....
Shamoo, A. E.
Mar 20, 2007

Corruption and Ethics: Number On....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Nov 16, 2006

Sprouting from Inequity: The Roo....
Shamoo, A. E. and Bricker, B.
Oct 12, 2006

Commentary: “Serious Harm By Res....
Shamoo, A. E. (Appeared in more than 15 newspapers worldwide)
May 06, 2006

Permanent U.S. Bases in Iraq are....
Shamoo, A. E.
Apr 16, 2006